NRL Round 5 chat


SC Playbook Forums 2021 NRL SuperCoach season NRL Round 5 chat

Viewing 32 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #1949191
      SC Playbook
      Keymaster

      Drop all your NRL SuperCoach questions and feedback ahead of Round 5 here.

    • #1949201
      Brew
      Participant

      Fifita 86 B+P looking a near must have 👀

      • #1949231
        michaelfisher
        Participant

        Agree Brew! Could be a decent captain option against some of there upcoming opponents as well

    • #1949202
      Brew
      Participant

      Prices have updated all. Scores locked in.
      Fifita out to 685k
      Papz up 150k.

    • #1949203
      Stu
      Participant

      Hoping for some strategic advice, I’m now at a stage that I want to downgrade a couple of my cheapies and then upgrade a couple of my mid ranges to guns. However all of the players I have in mind play in the round 13 bye. So do I still proceed in selling these players and upgrade my team, not sure which way to go. The players I’m talking about are the usual ones, Nui, Riki, Fuimaono, Brandon Smith, Staines, watson, Liddle, utoikamanu and J Brailey.

      • #1949232
        michaelfisher
        Participant

        It’s an interesting one Stuart. I think it depends on the opportunities in the position and how each of those players are going. I think a number of those players can be traded, ideally the weakest one’s first

    • #1949212
      Bevchenko
      Participant

      What trades are everyone looking at this week? Luckily To’o is in reach for me after being $9k off last week.

      • #1949233
        michaelfisher
        Participant

        Nice Bev! Fogarty to S Walker. Tupouiniua to Fifita. For me

    • #1949213
      Beagles
      Participant

      Thinking Fog to Swalker and then either JoO or Staines to Too.

    • #1949215
      King Gutho
      Participant

      currently sitting at a nice rank of 269 have riki to JFH locked in now i cant decide either to go momirovski or Gagai leaning towards momi due to him playing rnd 13 and reasonalbe draw

    • #1949224
      luther
      Participant

      Upgrading Niu this week, Val Holmes or Brian Kelly?

      • #1949238
        michaelfisher
        Participant

        I’d go Kelly in a better attacking side + should be available round 13

    • #1949226
      Miss Jane
      Participant

      Just curious as to who has max traded up to now? Is it more important to get Fifi this week for Matto or would you go Angus? Who knows if Matto is going to be a late no show again and he plays the last game again this week. I went early last week on To’o and was thinking about upgrading Nui to Olam. Thoughts??

      • #1949239
        michaelfisher
        Participant

        I’ve max traded miss Jane. Unfortunately has had to be done. I’d go Fifi out of those two – His BE is about 50 points lower

        • #1949248
          SC Playbook
          Keymaster

          Hey miss Jane, I’ve also max traded and am vary wary of it. Will be looking to save a couple of trades at some stages over the next three weeks, easier said than done though! I’d personally be tempted to go Crichton over Fifi. I think Crichton is absolutely elite, Fifita’s base still isn’t great, despite looking amazing in attack. Both are basically must-haves, but I’d narrowly go Crichton of the two. Tough call on Matto but he’s looking hard to hold with the uncertainty, just so scared he’ll cop an early knock for a low score again. Like the Niu-Olam play!

          – Tim W

    • #1949227
      Brew
      Participant

      @stuart I’m in a similar boat from next week. I’ll likely take a one cow cash out, one mid upgrade for a few weeks.

      Whilst doing this im keeping an eye on how it affects my bye numbers.

      Ultimately you need points to win this game so take them, just keep a safe medium with your bye number.

    • #1949228
      Brew
      Participant

      Kelly. Unless both are in your plans short term, then I’d go Val and get Kelly in a few weeks. @luther

    • #1949229
      Brew
      Participant

      @missjane
      Olam is a gun trade. Like it.
      Matters was confirmed by coach to be back this week during the tigers coverage. Up to you I’d be tempted to hold and work out a method to get Angus/ Fifita next week.

      Prefer Fifita this week, both must haves I reckon.

    • #1949235
      michaelfisher
      Participant

      • This reply was modified 3 months, 3 weeks ago by michaelfisher.
    • #1949240
      KerrodW
      Participant

      Gday,

      Have been trading every week and going alright at 930. Only have 2k itb.

      Is it stupid to trade Hudson young and Jordan Riki to get David fifita and then go Condon or topine? Feel like I don’t want to miss out on fifita but I could easily just hold trades as well.

      Thoughts?

      • #1949250
        SC Playbook
        Keymaster

        Hey Kerrod, tough one there. I think in that case you’d be getting rid of two very reliable scorers in Riki and Young, for one gun and a cheapie who may be gone by next week. There’s more money to be made in Young and Riki so I’d hold tight on those.

        – Tim W

        • #1949254
          KerrodW
          Participant

          Cheers Tim,

          Think that is probably the best play. Getting trade happy hahah

    • #1949241
      wadespeer1
      Participant

      Thoughts on playing Fusitua v Manly over Staines v Canberra?

    • #1949242
      wadespeer1
      Participant

      @KerrodW
      While Fifita is definitely going very well I don’t think those trades benefit you getting in someone who could be gone next week, Riki is still a safe play in 17s

      • This reply was modified 3 months, 3 weeks ago by wadespeer1.
      • This reply was modified 3 months, 3 weeks ago by wadespeer1.
      • #1949256
        KerrodW
        Participant

        Thanks Wade,

        Looking at it, I agree, just think I’m getting fomo not having fifita, but it’s the better play to hold.

    • #1949245
      Bevchenko
      Participant

      @wade I’m in the same situation, think Staines will find it tough, i’ll reluctantly be playing Fusi.

      • This reply was modified 3 months, 3 weeks ago by Bevchenko.
    • #1949249
      Jeff
      Participant

      Coming off a bit of a shocking start with some plays that have not played off (e.g. Sitili & Fogarty this week, although captained Papz). I’m out to 15k ranking, am going Fogarty to Swalker for cash because need to beef up CTW.

      Currently going Niu to To’o, but wondering whether to go Nofo as a points play this week based on PTH c Tigers match ups.

      Thoughts or other plays? (Hace Capewell and Laurie as only other locks CTW playing)

      • #1949251
        SC Playbook
        Keymaster

        Hey mate, trades look great to me. I think To’o is an absolute must, and his price is on the way up. With his base playing in a gun team I’d be getting him in over Nofa. Nofa’s price is dropping at the moment, so hopefully he can be picked up in a couple of weeks at a discount.

        – Tim W

    • #1949261
      luke richo
      Participant

      Hi team, like everyone have the Fifita issue. Considering Welch and Tupounia out for Fifita and Wilton. Wilton doesn’t sit well with me but loving Fifita (and Welch/Tupounia going ok but both could score 50 each week where Fifita could get that himself most weeks… I saved one trade earlier so if Wilton role changes can turn into James as a solid 40-50 reserve 2rf and would be happy with that. Current team below for full picture

      Brailey/Watson
      Paulo/Welch/stefano/Leniu
      Angus/Barnett/Tino/Tupounia/Riki/Blore
      Cleary/Walker
      Walker/Schuster
      Capewell/fergo/Laurie/Niu/Staines/Fus/suali
      Teddy/pap

    • #1949262
      Brew
      Participant

      Hey @jrharris

      Whilst Nofo has a potentially great matchup this week, Too base + upcoming draw is such a safe play.

      Nofo might drop a bit more in the meantime and you can grab him a little cheaper.

    • #1949263
      Brew
      Participant

      @lukericho if you can use Riki/ Tuponua to get to Fifita I’d do that.

      I’d be holding Welch myself for a few more week.

    • #1949265
      jakeh2020
      Participant

      Thinking of trading Hoy > niko
      Teddy to RTS

      Warriors have a great run vs cows and manly twice. Would have to not play niko when they play Melbourne and eels.

      Thoughts or am I trying to hard to find pods

    • #1949274
      Bevchenko
      Participant

      takes a brave man to get rid of Teddy!

    • #1949275
      Bevchenko
      Participant

      J Riki or R James for 17th man?

      • #1949279
        SC Playbook
        Keymaster

        Riki for me Bev, should play 80 minutes again, James only about 40. Decent attacking upside to Riki, bit of a HIA risk for James at the moment too.

        _ Tim W

    • #1949282
      Jeff
      Participant

      Thanks for the “not crazy” validation lol, and the reply in general.

      Have subscribed as really stoked with the content and what you’re building. Cheers weapons

    • #1949318

      I am thinking of trading Barnett to Fifita. Is that to sideways as it’s the only way I can get Fifita this week. Or do I downgrade Joe O to Wilton and use the cash next week for upgrading Welch to Fifita via duals? Thanks

    • #1949319
      jakeh2020
      Participant

      Hey all, I’m ranked top 1000.

      Thinking of trading teddy for the first time ever.

      Teddy > RTS
      Capewell > Dfifi

      What do you think of these trades?

    • #1949326
      Pablo Bill
      Participant

      I think it comes with great risk considering Ted ownership in top 1,000. Could be a masterstroke with RTS low ownership but I’d be backing Ted to outscore RTS week on week. A couple of failed attacking stats last week Ted missed and he would have cracked 100+ again.

      I’d be looking at an alternate way to get DFifi

    • #1949336
      Brew
      Participant

      @dirtymike I’d find another way. Barnett has a 75 average without the goal kicking.

    • #1949353
      Crystal2021
      Participant

      Tossing up playing S Crichton or R Smith?

    • #1949354
      Brew
      Participant

      If anyone has any last minute trade Q&A hit me up and I’ll help out!
      Nothing but time today 🙂

    • #1949355
      MunsterMash
      Participant

      So with a bunch of cheapies looking to be peaking in the next couple of weeks, what is everyone thinking of doing?

      – The Broncos play rd 13, do you hold Riki/Niu until then? I’m personally going to look to upgrade Niu as there are plenty of good CTW choices for the byes, but Riki might be a decent hold.
      – Any other cheapies worth holding until 13 beyond the obvious ones (Watson, Brailey)
      – What decent downgrade options stand out? Im definitely hoping Tuipulotu will get a run at the Sea Eagles, but don’t know of many others that are close? Maybe someone from the Warriors might pop up, like Curran?

      – Anyone got any idea on guys that could get a run around origin?

      • This reply was modified 3 months, 3 weeks ago by MunsterMash.
    • #1949357
      Brew
      Participant

      Egan Butcher, Sualli at the chooks. Hynes (unsure his price) at storm. Dunster at Parra. A bunch of Panthers too.

      Niu/ Riki hold unless it’s the difference in getting a gun. So many rounds until origin it’s a long hold. I’ll hold Niu if possible.

Viewing 32 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.