Final Say: Round 21, trade plans + tactics

With the clock running down until the beginning of Round 21, we have the final say on AFL SuperCoach trade plans.


I’ll start off by saying that I’m as shocked as all of you are. My crappy team does not deserve to be this high in the rankings, nor does my crappy personality deserve the sort of luck that went my way last week.

Now that that’s out the way – GET. AROUND. ME. After being stuck in the 400s since the byes, out of nowhere Eddie’s Eagles dropped a 2,557 in Round 20 – 417th for the round – vaulting me up to 268th overall. I wish I could say I deserved this, but I really didn’t.

This time last week everything in my gut was screaming at me to hold George Hewett and get rid of Jack Crisp instead, but at the last minute my (usually) stupid head won out and it was Hewett who paid the price at the Eagles’ selection table.

Thank christ for that. 

While Crisp still sucks – evidenced by his miserly 60 at the weekend – at least he’s not poised to miss the rest of the season, as reports are now suggesting might be the fate that’s befallen poor old Hewett. Not only is Hewett gone, so are Jacob Wehr and Massimo D’Ambrosio, leaving me (and many others) with very little defensive bench cover. I will return to this depressing theme later in this article.

PRICE DROP! Our subscription package is down to $20 for the remainder of the season. Support the site, and more importantly your SuperCoach side’s title bid, with extra premium articles, access to our Whatsapp group chat with exclusive insights and feedback. SIGN UP HERE!

Embed from Getty Images

That was the first factor that fell in my favour, with Tom Stewart putting up 112 delicious points as a Hewett replacement; 63 better than Wehr/D’Ambrosio. Then Stephen Coniglio popped up as a late withdrawal. “Shouldn’t that be a negative for your team, Eddie?” I hear you ask.

Not when I’ve somehow managed to end up with Jai Culley, Elijah Hollands and Ben Hobbs, all sitting on my mid/fwd bench waiting to be subbed on, with others either fielding zeroes or the likes of Corey Durdin (lol @CharlieDadds). Things got even better when popular replacement Culley stunk, but I fortuitously managed to avoid it by looping him at F7 and playing Hobbs instead.

I’m telling you – weeks like these don’t happen often. Did I mention I’m somehow still holding Mitch Owens?

Throw in a lazy 173 from Rowan Marshall, 146 from Patrick Cripps, 138 from Andrew Brayshaw and another glorious 140+ from Rory Laird as captain and it was time for me to invest in a few lottery tickets

Oh what could’ve been had Zach Merrett merely doubled his 40 point halftime score… With young tagger Lachie Ash out this week, I fear that not owning Merrett is only going to get even more painful.

Hard to be nitpicky when you’re sitting 250th and – with one trade left – could have an outside chance at the top 100 though. Big decisions to be made this week…

Embed from Getty Images



Remaining Salary: $148,200

Trades Left: 1 (0 boosts)

Gah. Every bone in my body is desperate to trade Jack Crisp to Angus Brayshaw this week. If just one of D’Ambrosio or Wehr was looking like being available for the final fortnight of the season, I would do it in a heartbeat.

Embed from Getty Images

Unfortunately that’s not the case, and while I’m well covered on other lines – thanks to Hobbs, Teakle, Hollands and Owens – it just feels like a rash decision to try and stumble home with 0 defensive bench cover and 0 trades. It’s hard to imagine a scenario where one of my 18 premiums doesn’t miss a game in these last three weeks, and the benefits of being able to trade them probably (PROBABLY) outweigh the satisfaction that would come from finally axing Crisp’s underperforming ass.

For the second week in a row I”m going to try and ignore my gut and instead use some modicum of logic on a completely illogical game. 

The attraction to Brayshaw is obvious – he’s an A grade midfielder when playing in the guts and it appears – for whatever reason – that Simon Goodwin has decided to throw him in there semi-permanently. He’s got back to back 120+ scores and there’s no reason to expect that won’t continue. Crisp, meanwhile, hasn’t tonned up since Round 13 and is genuinely at the point where if you have any semblance of bench cover, I’d be looping him at D7 for tonight’s game.

Need extra cash to help buy a new car or take your business to the next level? Whatever the goal, Pat and George from Mortgage choice are here to help you know your numbers.  Give them a call on (02) 9521 1611 or scan the QR Code below. Mention ‘SC PLAYBOOK’ for your FREE numbers consult. 

Eddie’s Captains

We are not worthy of the season Rory Laird is putting together. The little garden gnome’s lowest score since Round 11 is a 114 and his five-round average is 139. He cannot be stopped, and there’s little reason to expect anything different this week against a leaky West Coast, who continue to give up enormous midfield scores (153 to Touk last week, 143 to Steele the week before).

At this point, I think I’d need at least 140 from my vice captain to even consider not giving Garden Gnome the armband.

Speaking of VCs – Touk is an exceptionally good option. The Suns play the early Saturday game against the Hawks down in Tasmania. While Finn Maginness is in good form as a tagger, the Saints still managed three midfield tons last week + Marshall’s enormous 173. Touk has a 150+ score against the Hawks in 2021 and is averaging 142 in his last five games – don’t overthink it.

As far as other options go, Oliver against the ‘Pies on Friday night is worth a look – he scored 140 against them in their last contest and loves playing at the ‘G, with back-to-back 140s in his last two games there. Zach Merrett is averaging 139 in his last five games and, without the spectre of Lachie Ash hanging over him, is every chance to go ham.

Callum Mills plays North Melbourne, while Patrick Cripps is now averaging 135+ in games which George Hewett hasn’t played this season. Lachie Neale also still needs to be considered given the Blues gave up 144 to Laird last week.

Embed from Getty Images

Vice Captains

  1. Touk Miller
  2. Zach Merrett
  3. Clayton Oliver


  1. Rory Laird
  2. Callum Mills
  3. Lachie Neale

FANCY A SAME-GAME MULTI? Topsport offer the best in the business, where the market odds ACTUALLY add up. Give it a try, compare to other bookies, and see the difference for yourself! Use the code ‘SCPLAYBOOK’ when signing up.

TOPSPORT Bet of the Week

Andrew Brayshaw 30+ touches @1.86

Marcus Bontempelli 30+ touches @3.40

Collingwood 1-39 @2.30

Multi @14.54

Leave a Reply